It's not surprising that books about the wars we are in are so popular, but who would have thought some of the most popular readings would be U.S. Army doctrine? The purpose of doctrine is to provide guidance on how - and often why - to conduct operations. They used to be dry reads but now they are written to be accessible by those both inside and outside the military.
The U.S. Army/Marine Corps Counterinsurgency Field Manual, also known as FM 3-24, did remarkably well. The Army's recently revised Operations Manual, or FM 3-0, is also popular. However, while FM 3-24 still does reasonably well on Amazon (over a year old and it's in the top 5,000), the latest addition to the public library is the Stability Operations Manual, or FM 3-07. This is doing very well with apparently more then 250,000 downloads in the last three weeks. The growing popularity of official U.S. military instruction manuals is fascinating. It is likely a factor of both the militarization of our foreign policy and the transition of our Armed Forces to a learning organization that has the wherewithal and desire to understand and adapt to changing conditions.
The resources available to permit the time and manpower to develop these manuals and to reinforce the iterative learning processes is one the rest of Government lacks - save perhaps for the USIP. As a result, there has been a paucity of equivalent material aimed at policy-makers.
However, there is a new book that's due to hit the market next month that addresses this void: Counterinsurgency: A Guide for Policy-Makers. At The Washington Independent, Spencer Ackerman writes about the book:
There are lessons in the handbook that the U.S. government has clearly been reluctant to adopt. It explicitly instructs policy-makers to "co-opt" insurgents whenever possible -- something that the Bush administration's rhetoric about the "evils" of Iraqi and Afghan insurgents makes problematic."The purpose of COIN," the handbook says, "is to build popular support for a government while suppressing or co-opting an insurgent movement."
Kilcullen added that negotiations are a two-way street in counterinsurgency. "A government that offers [insurgents] no concessions [will] usually lose," he said, but "an insurgency that offers no concessions will usually lose." Another piece of advice -- one that resonates in the wake of the administration's torture scandals -- simply reads, "Respect People."
Similarly, the handbook attempts to integrate civilian and military agencies into a concerted strategy -- something the Bush administration has been unable to substantively accomplish in Iraq and Afghanistan. "COIN planning should integrate civilian and military capabilities across each of the four COIN strategy functions of security, politics, economics and information," it reads.
More to come here at MountainRunner.